Shin Godzilla (Official) was released on July 29, 2016, with Hideaki Anno as chief director and Shinji Higuchi as director. It earned 8.25 billion yen at the box office (Reference: “Motion Picture Producers Association of Japan, Inc. ‘2016 National Film Industry Statistics’“, in Japanese).
In Anno’s filmography, it sits at an intriguing point between Evangelion: 3.0 You Can (Not) Redo and Evangelion: 3.0+1.0 Thrice Upon a Time. For me, it was Godzilla and it was an Anno film—how could I not go?
Here, I want to share some of my own thoughts on Shin Godzilla.
In particular, I want to consider Goro Maki, who leaves behind a note that reads like a last testament: “I did as I pleased. Now you do the same.”
What did he do as he pleased, and what did he mean by telling everyone else to do the same?
Let’s begin by looking back at the story.
A warning before we begin: the following synopsis and discussion contain spoilers for the film.
*This is a translated version. The original (Japanese) is available here.
- The Enigma of Goro Maki and Godzilla’s Genesis
Maki pursues research into making radioactive materials harmless even as he hates Japan and humanity. I consider whether he caused a mutated marine organism to evolve into Godzilla. The unexplained origin of the creature also opens up a more fantastical reading: perhaps Maki merged with that organism—or became Godzilla independently of it—as a symbol of his hatred of radioactive materials. - Echoes of Eiichi Hoba from Patlabor: The Movie
Maki’s actions recall those of Eiichi Hoba in Mamoru Oshii’s Patlabor: The Movie. Hoba plans to destroy Tokyo with a computer virus and commits suicide at the beginning of the story. I read his suicide as an attempt to return in the form of the virus and become a god. This parallels my reading of Maki’s transformation into Godzilla. The similar story structures suggest a possible homage to Oshii. - Why Kayoko’s Casting Might Make Sense
I try to take a positive view of Satomi Ishihara’s casting. Kayoko’s presence feels out of place, but perhaps that very feeling makes her role as a convenient, necessary “lie” visible. A fuller account of why a Japanese-American character works so hard for Japan would, I think, require much more of her background to be shown and make the film considerably longer.
On this pageContents
Shin Godzilla (2016) Full Synopsis (Spoilers Ahead)
Quick Summary: A Nation Under Siege
- The Breach and the Birth of a God
A steam explosion in Tokyo Bay is followed by the appearance of an enormous tail. A giant creature comes ashore in Kamata, confronts the Self-Defense Forces and returns to the sea. The government establishes a task force to investigate it. The creature is understood to have evolved in response to nuclear waste, and it is named “Godzilla.” -
A Devastating Blow to the Cabinet
Godzilla reappears and advances on Tokyo despite the Self-Defense Forces’ attacks. U.S. aircraft also attack, but Godzilla shoots them down with its radioactive fire and burns Kasumigaseki. Government leaders die while evacuating, and Yusuke Satomi, the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, becomes acting Prime Minister. - Operation Yashiori: The Final Gambit
The task force devises Operation Yashiori, a plan to freeze Godzilla by targeting the cooling system of its internal nuclear reactor. With a U.S. nuclear attack looming, researchers around the world help make the plan possible. The operation succeeds, but Godzilla remains frozen in the city, leaving the question of how to live alongside it.
Character Map: The Bureaucrats vs. The Beast
Let’s now look at the story of Shin Godzilla in a little more detail.
Detailed Synopsis: The Evolution of Terror
The Appearance of a Giant Creature
At 8:30 a.m. on November 3, an unoccupied pleasure boat is found in Tokyo Bay. While it is being searched, a steam explosion occurs in the bay. The Aqua-Line tunnel is damaged and begins to flood.
The government considers a submarine volcanic eruption among the possible causes and prepares an announcement. Then an enormous tail emerges from the sea. The steam explosion was caused not by a natural phenomenon, but by a giant creature.
Deputy Chief Cabinet Secretary Rando Yaguchi had raised that possibility early on. His concern turns out to be justified.
While the government decides whether to capture or eliminate it, the creature moves through the bay and comes ashore in Kamata, in Tokyo’s Ota Ward.
The creature crawls forward on all fours, destroying houses around it. Residents evacuate, but casualties begin to occur.
An order is issued for the Japan Self-Defense Forces (JSDF) to begin a defense operation.
At almost the same moment, the creature roars and rises onto two legs. It seems to be doing more than lifting its body: it looks as though it is “evolving.”
The creature, now on two legs, faces the JSDF helicopters. An attack is ordered, then temporarily halted when people are spotted nearby. At that point, for reasons that remain unclear, the creature returns to the sea.
Naming the Terror: Godzilla
To combat the unprecedented threat, the government forms the “Giant Unidentified Lifeform Task Force,” operating directly out of the Prime Minister’s Office.
Its members, led by Yaguchi as secretary-general, are an eccentric bunch: “the misfits of Kasumigaseki, the heretics of academia.”
Meanwhile, unusually high radiation levels are detected in Tokyo.
The areas with unusually high radiation levels match the creature’s route. From this, the task force infers that the creature is the source of the radiation and generates energy through nuclear fission inside its body.
The United States is also concerned and calls on Japan to respond. Kayoko Ann Patterson, a special envoy of the U.S. President, contacts Yaguchi.
Kayoko asks him to search for Dr. Goro Maki, a scientist who had been driven out of Japan and continued his research in the United States. Maki had reportedly predicted the creature’s appearance several years earlier. Although a biologist, he worked at an energy-related research institute.
The United States had been unable to trace Maki’s movements since he arrived in Japan seven days earlier.
Yaguchi agrees to search for Maki in exchange for information about the creature. He establishes that Maki was the person aboard the pleasure boat found in Tokyo Bay on November 3.
Maki had left a note on the boat that reads like a last testament: “I did as I pleased. Now you do the same.” Yaguchi hands the note and Maki’s other belongings to Kayoko and receives data on Maki and the creature in return.
The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) knew of an aquatic organism that fed on nuclear waste and had commissioned private-sector research into it. Maki, who undertook that research, proposed that nuclear waste had been dumped into a habitat where an ancient organism had survived, causing it to change rapidly into a radiation-resistant life form.
Maki named the organism “Godzilla,” after Gojira, a sea god in the folklore of his home island, Odo. The Japanese government announces that it will call the unidentified creature “Gojira.”
A Devastating Blow to the Cabinet
Yaguchi’s task force uses the data from Kayoko to study Godzilla. She also supplies a sheet covered in mysterious patterns that Maki left behind, but no one can make sense of it.
While the government and the task force prepare their response, Godzilla reappears off Sagami Bay.
It is larger now, and its appearance is more ominous.
This time, the JSDF attacks immediately. The attack has no effect, and Godzilla continues its advance toward central Tokyo.
The United States, which had seemed to be watching from the sidelines, announces that aircraft are on their way from Guam for the stated purpose of “embassy defense.”
The Japanese government then announces that it has requested cooperation under the U.S.-Japan Security Treaty. U.S. forces will attack Godzilla in Tokyo, and government leaders begin evacuating the capital.
When the U.S. aircraft attack, Godzilla shoots them down with powerful radioactive fire.
The fire also burns through Kasumigaseki. The Prime Minister and other ministers evacuating by helicopter are caught in it and disappear along with the aircraft.
After moving a short distance farther, Godzilla becomes motionless in front of Tokyo Station.
Operation Yashiori: The Freeze
With the Prime Minister gone, Yusuke Satomi, the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, who happened to survive, becomes acting Prime Minister.
The task force has already been considering a plan to attack Godzilla’s cooling system, based on the fact that it has a nuclear reactor inside its body.
Unexpectedly, the loss of the prime minister and much of his cabinet makes it possible to put that plan into action.
Meanwhile, the United States begins considering nuclear weapons as a way to eliminate the fundamental threat Godzilla poses, and presses the Japanese government to accept that option.
Yaguchi and the task force prepare the “Yaguchi Plan,” determined to prevent the use of nuclear weapons at all costs.
As they learn more about Godzilla’s biology, it becomes clear that carrying out the plan will require complex calculations.
Despite the difficulties, many outstanding researchers around the world agree to use their institutes’ supercomputers to make the Yaguchi Plan possible. They do so with nothing to gain—only risk.
Yaguchi names his plan to freeze Godzilla “Operation Yashiori.”
The operation succeeds, though not without many difficulties and sacrifices.
But Godzilla remains there, frozen.
How are we to live with its presence?
Shin Godzilla: Goro Maki, Kayoko, and the Film’s Mysteries
What Did Goro Maki Ultimately Do as He Pleased?
Goro Maki is central to the story of Shin Godzilla, yet we never see him in person. He leaves behind a note, as though it were his last testament: “I did as I pleased. Now you do the same.”
His shoes were left neatly together on the boat, so it seems safe to conclude that he took his own life by jumping into the sea.
The following details offer clues to his actions:
- Maki had been driven out of Japan’s academic community.
- The DOE commissioned him to investigate Godzilla at an early stage.
- He had predicted Godzilla’s appearance several years earlier.
- His wife died from the effects of radiation.
- Her death led him to research ways of making radioactive materials harmless.
- Japan appears to have left his wife to die.
- He hated humanity itself for continuing to produce radioactive materials.
What the film alone does not make clear is how Japan “left his wife to die.” How could that have happened?
To consider that, I think we need to look at Maki’s age and generation. The document Yaguchi receives from Kayoko contains the years “1962,” “1959” and “1957.” Below 1962, it reads:
Teito University
Department of Integrative Biology, Graduate School
Faculty of Molecular Cell Biology
This suggests that 1962 was the year he received his doctorate, with a bachelor’s degree in 1957 and a master’s in 1959. On a conventional academic path, he would have been about 27 or 28 in 1962, putting his birth around 1935.
If his wife was of the same generation, she may have been exposed to the atomic bombing of Hiroshima or Nagasaki. Perhaps, then, her illness was not officially recognized as being caused by the atomic bombing.
No wonder he was angry.
References
- About Atomic Bomb Disease Certification (Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare), in Japanese
- Atomic Bomb Disease Lawsuits (Ministry of Justice), in Japanese
- The Atomic Bomb Disease Certification Lawsuits and the Facts Revealed Within Them (Japan Anti-Nuclear Lawyers Association), in Japanese
In those circumstances, Maki continued researching ways to make radioactive materials harmless while harboring hatred for Japan and humanity.
How conflicted he was.
With his wife gone, his research could only benefit people other than her—the very humanity he had come to hate.
All he could do was leave everything in the hands of humanity. He could no longer decide anything for himself.
On this reading, what he did was cause the mutated marine organism the DOE had detected to evolve into Godzilla.
But we know almost nothing about how he might have done it.
Shin Godzilla tries to ground its story in science fiction, offering explanations for Godzilla’s presence and the response to it. Yet how Godzilla first appears—or comes into being—remains unclear.
Looking at it another way, perhaps no specific mechanism was established in the first place. Maki’s actions and Godzilla’s appearance may belong more to fantasy, to be understood in terms of powerful emotion or something spiritual.
That leaves only a few possibilities: Maki merged with the marine organism and became Godzilla, or he became Godzilla independently of it.
A merger would fit the story’s progression to some extent, but it still leaves the question of how he brought the organism into Tokyo Bay.
Could it be, then, that Goro Maki threw himself into the sea and became Godzilla, a symbol of his hatred of radioactive materials?
Perhaps Maki, torn between these conflicting feelings, became Godzilla as a symbol of his destructive impulse, yet left a way to counter it—trying to make the contest just barely fair.
His decision to begin everything in Japan reveals his despair over his homeland. Even so, I feel a certain respect for Dr. Maki’s attempt to keep the contest fair.
Goro Maki and Eiichi Hoba: Echoes of Patlabor
Watching Shin Godzilla, I could not help thinking of Mamoru Oshii. There were many moments when the dialogue and the film’s overall atmosphere felt distinctly “Oshii-like.”
Nowhere is this more apparent than in the character of Goro Maki.
The key point is that Maki himself added “God” to the English name “Godzilla.” In this reading, Godzilla is a god. By taking his own life, Maki became Godzilla and, at the same time, became a god.
A character in an Oshii film did almost the same thing: Eiichi Hoba in Patlabor: The Movie.
Hoba commits suicide at the beginning of the story. He has planted a virus in a newly developed operating system, planning to make the Labors in Tokyo go berserk and destroy the city.
His suicide was intended to perfect his plan, but perhaps he also meant to return as the virus and destroy Tokyo as a god. (For more, see my discussion of Patlabor: The Movie.)
The two films have strikingly similar basic story structures. Maki and Hoba also have something else in common: both are, fundamentally, a nuisance to everyone else.
Perhaps Shin Godzilla as a whole was an homage to Mamoru Oshii.
That concludes my discussion of Goro Maki, but I would like to consider a few other things.
The Mystery of Kayoko Ann Patterson
We cannot discuss Shin Godzilla without considering Kayoko Ann Patterson, played by Satomi Ishihara.
Kayoko is Japanese-American, with a Japanese grandmother. Surely anyone watching the film wondered: Couldn’t they have cast a Japanese-American actress?
Here, though, I want to take as positive a view of that casting as I can. Where might we start?
Point 1: Why Kayoko Feels Out of Place
The first thing to notice is the feeling that something is out of place.
In other words, Kayoko is an “incongruous presence” within the film.
But in what sense is she out of place?
Think of how devotedly Kayoko works for Japan. It is certainly her grandmother’s homeland, but her grandmother’s, not her own. Kayoko’s homeland is the United States.
Perhaps she works so hard because her presence is an important “lie” that the film needs.
A story about Godzilla rampaging through present-day Japan needs someone to act as a bridge to the United States. But that person cannot be merely a go-between; they also have to be strongly sympathetic to Japan.
In reality, there probably is no such conveniently sympathetic person.
Yet the story needs her to move forward. As such a convenient “lie,” her character also needs to make that artificiality apparent.
Could that be one way to explain the casting?
Point 2: The Burden of Realism
There is another question worth asking about Kayoko: what would have happened if a Japanese-American actress had played her?
My prediction is that Shin Godzilla would have been an hour longer.
Identity is a sensitive and serious matter for Japanese-Americans and for others described as “hyphenated Americans.” Nor is that question limited to the United States. To make a Japanese-American character’s efforts on Japan’s behalf convincing, the story would need to show her background properly.
But that would make the film enormously long. An extra hour might not even be enough.
I love films, and when it comes to Anno’s work, I would happily watch even a five-hour Shin Godzilla. People who do not share that enthusiasm certainly would not—and who would distribute a film like that in the first place?
On that reasoning, the role of the go-between with the United States could not be given to an actual Japanese-American. The character is simply too convenient for the story of Shin Godzilla.
Seen this way, there was a strong reason for a Japanese actress to play Kayoko, and I think Satomi Ishihara gave the role her all.
Why Can’t We Defeat Godzilla?
By the end of Shin Godzilla, Godzilla has not been decisively defeated.
That is not unique to this film: many Godzilla films end in much the same way. It is rare for Godzilla to be killed after wreaking havoc.
Why can’t we defeat Godzilla?
I have collected my thoughts on that question in a separate article.
Read the discussion here: Why We Can Never Truly Kill Godzilla in Shin Godzilla.
Why is it that we cannot defeat him?








Reader Comments
Have a thought or interpretation? Leave a comment