Better Call Saul is an AMC drama spun off from Breaking Bad. In that series, Saul Goodman is the crooked lawyer who’s very good at showing Walter White how to launder money. Here we meet him as Jimmy McGill, a lawyer trying to make an honest living. We see how he becomes Saul and what happens to him after Breaking Bad.
I loved the show, but Jimmy’s choices kept throwing me. Just when I thought I understood the kind of person he was, he’d do something that made me think again. I keep coming back to three things when I think about him. The same fights with his older brother Chuck happen over and over. He depends on people even as he tries to break away from them. And he cares far more about what he gets done than about how he does it. By the end, those three things tell me something about who Saul Goodman really was.
Spoilers for the entire series follow.
*This is a translated version. The original (Japanese) is available here.
- The same fights keep getting bigger. Jimmy and Chuck’s conflict repeats with higher stakes each time, a pattern you can see in Suits and Breaking Bad as well. The characters’ ways of thinking stay remarkably close to where they began.
- Jimmy and Kim take it out on Howard Hamlin. After Chuck dies, the danger Jimmy and Kim have brought into their lives through the cartel helps explain why their campaign against Howard goes so far. They still depend on him in a way they scarcely seem to recognize, and they unwittingly bring about his ruin.
- Everybody needs something to hold on to. Jimmy takes his cues from Chuck and Kim about how to get along in the world, yet he’s capable of going his own way. I think the tension between those impulses is what makes him so interesting.
- Lalo Salamanca shows what Jimmy might look like without any obligation to society. Lalo is brilliant and devoted to his family. People outside it mean nothing to him. Jimmy can break the law and still care whether someone lives or dies.
- Jimmy winds up somewhere surprisingly close to Chuck. Chuck stands for doing things properly, yet I wonder what he did to get where he was. Jimmy gets remarkable results as Saul. Taking back the McGill name in court feels like the closest the brothers get to a reconciliation.
On this pageContents
How Better Call Saul Keeps Raising the Stakes
Jimmy wants Chuck to respect him. A problem comes up, Jimmy finds an ingenious way around it, and the brothers fight over how he did it. The quarrel gets bigger every time. After Chuck dies, Jimmy and Kim take things further with Howard, and Lalo forces Jimmy to find out how far he can go and where he still draws the line.
The Cycle That Lasts Until Chuck’s Death
The early episodes have a wonderfully simple pattern.
- Jimmy tries to practice law the respectable way and earn his brother’s approval.
- Some new problem comes up.
- Jimmy solves it in a way nobody else would have thought of.
- Chuck objects to his methods, and they fight.
Jimmy wants Chuck to recognize what he’s capable of. Chuck can’t bring himself to give him that. After a while I started to wonder whether Jimmy really loved him, or whether Chuck felt any affection for Jimmy. They fall out and make up so often, and sometimes they seem genuinely bent on destroying each other. You can shrug and say that’s family for you. The sheer number of times it happens threw me.
It made more sense when I thought about how the show was written. Suits keeps cycling through a lie, a crisis, a furious dressing-down from Harvey, an apology, forgiveness, and a happy ending. The job titles and the trouble change. Early Breaking Bad has a loop of its own. They cook meth, make a pile of money, get into trouble, and lose it all. It practically started out as a comedy, didn’t it?
Jimmy and Chuck’s fight repeats at higher stakes, while their basic attitudes stay the same. I find it helps to watch each crisis through to its end. When another starts, I think, “Here we go again, only bigger.” You can still recognize the people you met in season one.
Why Jimmy and Kim Go After Howard
The pattern makes sense up through Chuck’s death. What gives me the most trouble is the campaign Jimmy and Kim wage against Howard afterward.
What Jimmy Resents About Howard
Howard is a decent guy who has no idea how condescending he comes across. When he offers Jimmy a job at Hamlin, Hamlin & McGill, he sincerely believes he’s doing him a favor. To Jimmy it feels like charity.
By then Jimmy is already mixed up with the cartel. He’s always trusted himself to find a way out of anything, and now he’s in over his head. Meanwhile Howard is still exactly the same guy. I can see why Jimmy would resent how casually Howard talks down to him, and how little Howard has had to change while Jimmy’s whole life has changed. That still leaves the question of why Jimmy and Kim go as far as they do.
The Pressure of Living in Fear
If what bothers you is that someone talks down to you, you can tell them to their face. Jimmy actually does tell Howard, and the campaign still goes ahead. I think it has a lot to do with the stress of knowing the cartel could get them killed. They need some way to get through their days without thinking about that constantly. A little distraction would hardly do it. It has to be something they can throw themselves into. For a man as sure of his abilities as Jimmy, this may be the first time he’s come up against something he can’t handle on his own.
Jimmy and Kim take their fear out on Howard even as they depend on him. The lengths they go to tell you something about the pressure they’re under. And I doubt either of them imagines their scheme will actually ruin him. Resenting Howard and relying on him somehow go hand in hand.
What the Characters Depend On
Once you notice what Howard means to Jimmy and Kim, you start to see what everyone in the show depends on.
- Jimmy needs Chuck as someone to look up to.
- Chuck needs Jimmy to stay a screwup.
- Howard leans on Chuck’s reputation.
- Kim depends on her pro bono work.
- Mike needs to be needed.
- Mike’s daughter-in-law holds on to the loss of her husband.
While they’re going after Howard, Kim depends on Jimmy too. He looks to her to show him how to get along in the world, much as he once looked to Chuck.
Everybody needs something to hold on to, and part of Jimmy’s appeal is watching him go beyond what he depends on. I don’t think needing something to get you through life is a bad thing. It makes these people feel like us. When Jimmy manages to get free of what he’s been relying on, it’s exhilarating. You might think that makes the series a celebration of independence. Then Lalo turns up.
Lalo Is Jimmy Without a Sense of Obligation to Society
Lalo is smart, perceptive, tough, and almost impossible to discourage. He sounds awfully appealing when you put it like that. He’s also free of any obligation to the society that Jimmy and the others are still tangled up in. Lalo respects Hector deeply and goes to great lengths for him, just as Jimmy does for Chuck. His loyalty ends with the family. People outside it mean nothing to him.
Lalo has Jimmy’s resourcefulness and devotion, but Jimmy still cares whether another person lives or dies. Jimmy’s idea of what’s acceptable is a long way from most people’s. He’ll bend the law, then break it outright. Yet the little he still owes to other people is what makes him appealing to me. He wants to get free of society and still depends on it for a sense of how to live. That back-and-forth is the hardest thing to get a handle on about Jimmy, and it’s what the story is about.
Jimmy Wants Results and the People Around Him Care How He Gets Them
Why does Jimmy keep coming into conflict with the people around him? I think it comes down to which matters more to you, the result or how you got there.
“The result, obviously!” you might say. In practice, most of us pay more attention to how things are done. That’s one reason I think so few people achieve what we call success. While the rest of us are still saying, “What are we going to do?” and putting it off, they’ve already decided what they’re going to do and gone ahead, even if it’s a little questionable.
The people Jimmy comes up against have generally made it in life. Once you have that much standing, you have to care how you go about things. Being a lawyer probably has something to do with it too. Jimmy goes straight for the result while the people who’ve already made it worry about the proper way to get there. He ends up getting better results than anybody, and what he does with them is up to him. There’s real pleasure in seeing a guy who was supposed to go nowhere pull off something that people high above him can’t.
We can admire that about Jimmy and still spend our own lives worrying about doing things properly, with little to show for it. Maybe that’s exactly why he looks so cool.
Saul Goodman Is Charles McGill
To get at who Saul Goodman is, I want to start with the person Jimmy spent so much time trying to impress. Charles McGill is the brother Jimmy measures himself against, and the way Chuck gets what he wants makes me wonder how much separates them.
Chuck Is Hard to Pin Down Too
To Jimmy, Chuck stands for what’s right and for the society in which he’s trying to earn a place. Then you think about two things he does.
- He goes to extraordinary lengths to get Jimmy disbarred.
- He shows just how good he is at getting a client back when he takes Mesa Verde away from Kim.
We never see what Chuck did to win the biggest cases of his career. The bigger the result, the harder it is to imagine he got it by playing nice. At work, Chuck may have been every bit as willing as Jimmy to do whatever it took to get a result. That’s where I start to see who Saul Goodman was.
How Jimmy Becomes the Lawyer Chuck Was
Early on, Jimmy finds a promising line of work in elder law. As Saul Goodman, he ends up defending the guys you’d cross the street to avoid. It’s a world away from Chuck’s practice. Yet both of them keep delivering extraordinary results. If you count the number of times they pulled off a miracle, Jimmy might win by a mile.
On the bus to prison, the other inmates all start chanting “Better call Saul!” He’s a hero to outsiders the way Chuck commands deep respect in the legal profession. Jimmy and Chuck both become great lawyers, each in a world that has little use for the other.
When Jimmy speaks in court for the last time, he at last gets past his fight with Chuck and takes back the name McGill. I wish Chuck had been there for it. Jimmy saying his own name again feels like a reconciliation between the two of them. After all those years of fighting his brother, Jimmy finally gets to where Chuck was.
That’s how I came to think about Saul Goodman. I probably ought to say more about Kim, but what I had to say didn’t quite fit here, and it wasn’t that much anyway. I found Better Call Saul fascinating. What kind of show was it for you?
Reader poll








Reader Comments
Have a thought or interpretation? Leave a comment